Quebec's pop diva is the synthesis of the francophone
experience -- descended from French culture, surrounded
by an Anglo-Saxon one and living like an American.
By
Konrad Yakabuski
The Globe and Mail
May 24, 1997
Montreal -- AFTER triumphant appearances at the Grammys,
Oscars and Olympics, Celine Dion insinuated herself
ever deeper into the American consciousness this week
with a cameo on The Nanny, a run-of-the-mill CBS TV sitcom.
This rather unremarkable feat -- at least compared
to the performance of pop music's reigning princess
before a potential 3.5 billion viewers at the opening
of the Atlanta Games -- was nevertheless much remarked
upon in Quebec. In fact, just about anything Ms. Dion
does spawns reams of television footage, scores of
newspaper articles and an assortment of magazine covers
in her native province. To Quebeckers, whose fixation
with pop culture has always made them the most American
of Canadians, she is realizing the American dream and
taking them along for the fabulous ride.
The few French phrases that Ms. Dion reserved for
her Quebecois fans during her acceptance speech at
the Grammy Awards in February, uttered in a joual inaccessible
to almost everyone but her six million French-speaking
compatriots, validated their unique and enduring culture.
In front
of the United States and the world, Ms. Dion proved
to Quebeckers that they exist.
In the star-crazed principality of Quebec, it was
worth more than a trillion distinct-society clauses.
Pop culture -- like politics -- is approached with
cult-like fervour in Quebec. With its flourishing home-grown
music and television industries, and its thriving supermarket
gossip tabloids, star worship has been elevated to an
art form in La Belle Province.
But never has a pop star penetrated the psyche of
Quebeckers as deeply as Celine Dion. At barely 29,
she is easily the most revered person in Quebec today,
surpassing even Premier Lucien Bouchard, the hero of
the 1995 referendum. According to a recent study by
a Montreal marketing firm, fully 99.3 per cent of Quebeckers
could identify Ms. Dion compared to 98.8 per cent who
knew Mr. Bouchard. And in a recent Leger & Leger
poll, only 68.5 per cent of Quebeckers had a favourable
opinion of the Premier, while 90 per cent had only
good things to say about Ms. Dion.
Her deification in her home province speaks volumes
about the social and political significance of pop
culture. For political scientist Christian Dufour,
Ms. Dion is an icon the likes of which has not been
known
in Quebec since the hockey heyday of Maurice "The
Rocket" Richard
in the 1950s.
"Her successes are the successes of all Quebecois,
much as the Rocket's goals were consolation for the
humiliations experienced by French Canadians in the past," observes
Mr. Dufour, a professor at l'Ecole nationale d'administration
publique in Montreal, in an essay written shortly after
Ms. Dion opened the Molson Centre last year. The event
was
rife with symbolism: Almost everyone agreed that the
heir to the Rocket's aura was a natural choice to inaugurate
the city's new hockey temple.
Celine Dion is the first star of planetary proportions
ever to emerge from Quebec. She has sold close to 55
million albums. Since the release of Falling Into You
in March last year, more than 22 million copies of
the recording have found their way into CD and cassette
players around the globe. The album clinched her status
as the world's best-selling recording artist in 1996
and catapulted the "Diva of Pop" onto the
cover of Time's international edition. At 6.5 million
copies, 1995's D'eux (the title is a play on the French
words for "two" and "of them," marking
her first professional collaboration with Paris producer
Jean-Jacques Goldman) is the best-selling French-language
recording of all time. In her native language she tackles
more inspired arrangements and compelling themes than
she does in English, such as love in the age of AIDS
(L'amour existe encore) and a girl's unrequited love
for a gay man (Ziggy). The French now compare her to
Edith Piaf, the character she is expected to play when
she
launches (oh yes) her Hollywood career.
To an outsider, it may seem paradoxical that Ms. Dion
could be held in such high esteem by Quebeckers, a
population that goes to tortuous lengths to assert
its distinct political and cultural identity. Here
is a
woman who, en route to international success, has dropped
the accent from her name on English promotional material
at the insistence of her record company, and reduced
herself to belting out insipid, formulaic pop tunes
in English that smother the nuances of her ethereal
voice. But it is precisely because she has been able
to do this and remain fully loyal to her unpretentious
Quebec roots and juggle a separate French singing career
that she has become such a powerful symbol for Quebeckers.
She has succeeded in reconciling the three competing
forces with which her francophone compatriots have
struggled since the Conquest. "Descended from
a French culture, surrounded by an Anglo-Saxon one
and
living like Americans -- these are the elements that
sum Quebeckers up," notes pollster Jean-Marc Leger. "Celine
Dion is the perfect embodiment of the happy balance
[of these forces] to which Quebeckers aspire."
As Mr. Dufour sees it, she "has realized the
harmonious synthesis -- still elusive on the political
front -- between the old French Canada, closed and Catholic,
and modern Quebec, open to the world."
Quebeckers watched in awe last month as these two
worlds met -- without colliding -- on U.S. television
when Ms. Dion, her unilingual parents and 13 siblings
fielded questions about their roots on The Oprah Winfrey
Show.
One need only pick up a local newspaper to appreciate
the extent to which Quebeckers have appropriated each
of her successes as their very own. The French-language
media refer possessively to the chanteuse as "notre
Celine nationale"("our national Celine").
WHEN her plane landed at Montreal's Mirabel airport after
a triumphant European concert tour last year, Radio-Canada's
all-news channel, le Reseau de l'information, broadcast
the event live. Two years earlier, the main network interrupted
its regular schedule to broadcast her wedding at Montreal's
gothic Notre-Dame Basilica.
Can anyone imagine Newsworld doing the same for Bryan
Adams? Moreover, would English Canadians care enough
to watch?
Quebeckers did. And Montreal publisher Trustar made
a small fortune by selling 1.3 million copies of a
souvenir wedding album that hit the newsstands only
a couple of days after the nuptials. When she arrived
home earlier this month for four sold-out shows at
Montreal's Molson Centre, the media paparazzi wanted
to know -- before anything else -- whether she was
pregnant. Headlines in the following day's newspapers
announced
the long-waited response: " Celine n'est pas enceinte"("Celine
is not pregnant"). The sense of collective disappointment
was palpable.
It prompted Le Journal de Montreal to ask its readers,
in a telephone poll, whether or not she should take
a break from her magnificent career to have a baby. Eighty-two
per cent of them said yes. This abiding interest in
her personal life, Mr. Leger opines, demonstrates how
strongly Quebeckers consider her to be "one of the
family."
This was not always the case.
All Quebeckers remember the homely adolescent who, only a few years ago, was
the subject of cruel jokes and scathing ridicule in her native province. As
the youngest of 14 children born to high-school dropouts
Therese and Adhemar Dion in tiny Charlemagne, Ms. Dion represented a parochial
past that Quebeckers had long ago rejected.
"For a long time, intellectual Quebeckers of the Quiet Revolution were
ashamed of this past," notes Mr. Dufour. And Ms. Dion, with her double-digit,
Roman Catholic family, suffered the brunt of their shame and rejection.
Her kitschy hymns to John Paul II, during his 1984 Canadian papal visit, prompted
sneers in post-Quiet Revolution cultural circles and were parodied for years
by Quebec humorists. Quebec's leading humour magazine of the 1980s, Croc, took
to calling the gangly adolescent "Canine Dion." In her public appearances,
with "Maman" Dion hovering over her, she gushed about wanting to
be the "biggest star in the world." Quebeckers snickered.
"She wasn't simply perceived as ketaine [tacky, hickish]," Mr. Leger says.
"She was ketaine."
As she attained sexual maturity, vicious innuendo circulated about her relationship
with her manager, Rene Angelil, who is 26 years her senior.
The attacks sent her close to the breaking point. In a 1992 television interview
with talk-show host Lise Payette, Ms. Dion wept profusely about the treatment
she had endured from much of the Quebec public. The now legendary interview
was also a turning point from which she has never looked back. The following
year she released Colour of My Love,the breakthrough album that made her an
international superstar, with sales of 15 million copies.
Since then, ne'er a disparaging word is heard in Quebec about "la petite
fille de Charlemagne"-- another of the nicknames that has followed her
since childhood. Attacking her has become something of a taboo.
"She has earned the respect of her detractors," says author and
journalist Georges-Hebert Germain, who is preparing a biography of the singer. "For
years, the cultural elite tried to diminish the importance of her success.
That is simply no longer possible."
In fact, one must look outside Quebec to find any press on her that does not
border on the obsequious. It was the Paris-based gossip rags that first dared
to print that the waif-like Ms. Dion was suffering from anorexia nervosa. The
rumour gained little currency in Quebec, where even the gossip mags paint her
as a secular Mother Teresa.
Her relationship with her husband Mr. Angelil, the impresario who has masterfully
executed her transformation from the hokey character out of Hymn Sing into
a sexy, sultry star, also appears to be off limits in the Quebec media. This
is not the case in France.
"Did Celine Dion marry her father?" the French magazine Psychologies
asked last fall. "It is dangerous to try to analyze the dynamic that exists
between two people one does not know intimately. But marrying the man who 'made'
you is, symbolically, not unrelated to the presence of deep-rooted Oedipal
fantasies. It is also a way to become the wife-daughter of a man one has put
on a pedestal."
Wittingly or not, Ms. Dion cultivates this "little girl" persona.
It is there on the Falling into You album cover, as she tugs mischievously
on her T-shirt to expose her navel. It was there when, in a video broadcast
at last year's Felix awards in Quebec, she addressed her fans with a large,
stuffed toy in the background.
For Psychologies, Ms. Dion's marriage to Mr. Angelil -- who has managed her
since she was 13 -- is like "a security blanket that bears witness to
the difficulty some women experience in attaining adult female maturity, in
displacing their mother from her position as the ideal woman."
Almost everyone in Quebec has heard the story of how Therese Dion, pregnant
with her seventh child in 1954, climbed daily up the ladder with a hammer to
help build her rapidly growing family's home in a hamlet east of Montreal.
"Never once did my mother let her pregnancies get in the way of her responsibilities
or the needs of her family," Ms. Dion boasted in an interview last year.
In short, Maman Dion has been a tough act to follow for Ms. Dion and her eight
sisters.
Quebec author Gabrielle Roy provides a portrait of the archetypal French-Canadian
family in The Tin Flute, her 1945 novel of poverty and despair in Montreal's
Saint-Henri neighbourhood. "La mere sacrifiee" (the mother-martyr)
stands out as a predominant figure in the novel. Rose-Anna Lacasse, who gives
birth to her umpteenth child on her daughter's wedding day, teaches us all
a lesson in self-sacrifice. She has not a minute to herself, what with her
futile, endless search for an affordable apartment to shelter her burgeoning
clan and what with husband Azarius's chronic unreliability and unemployment.
But Rose-Anna runs a tight ship. She is a veritable rock, holding her family
together through adversity and suffering. It is impossible to think of Maman
Dion, who at 70 has acquired an enormous public profile of her own in Quebec,
without also thinking of Rose-Anna. Except that her story is The Tin Flute
with a happy ending.
"Mr. Dion doesn't have the same drive as Maman Dion. He doesn't have
the same openness to the world," notes Mr. Germain, Ms. Dion's biographer. "It's
always been the mother who has pushed the kids."
Always the referee, it was Maman who, in 1992, intervened when her youngest
daughter created a stir at home by launching an emotional plea for national
unity at the World's Fair in Seville, Spain. "When there's 14 of you around
the table, you can have 14 different opinions. Not talking about politics is
the best way to avoid fights."
This was the same Ms. Dion who, in 1990, refused to accept the Felix award
(Quebec's Juno) for best anglophone singer of the year. "The public knows
I'm still Quebecoise and francophone, even when I sing in English."
For Christian Dufour, these two events illustrate the extent to which she
embodies the "classic ambivalence" of most Quebeckers -- fiercely
proud and defensive of their francophone heritage yet fundamentally attached
to their Canadian identity. Most Quebeckers identify instinctively with the
internal turmoil that generated both of her declarations. It is the turmoil
that has torn families apart in Quebec during two referendum campaigns and
countless elections. Is it any wonder that Celine Dion has become such a powerful
symbol in Quebec today?
All material copyright Thomson Canada Limited or its licensors. All rights
reserved.
|